Miami Beach · Private Island Estate Community
Thirty-four waterfront estate lots on a single guarded loop in Biscayne Bay — among South Florida's most recognized private-island residential addresses.
Community data last verified September 1, 2026
A 1922 dredged island in Biscayne Bay, connected to the MacArthur Causeway by a single bridge — the nearest of the causeway islands to South Beach, with Palm and Hibiscus Islands immediately west.
Every lot fronts the bay along the island's full perimeter — protected deep water, minutes by boat from Government Cut and the open Atlantic.
One bridge, one staffed guard gate, screening every arrival around the clock. One loop road inside — Star Island Drive — with no through traffic.
34 estate lots and nothing else: no interior parcels, no condominiums, no commercial uses. Parcels run to multiple acres of waterfront land.
Restored 1920s-era villas beside contemporary new construction — the island rebuilds continuously, and even teardowns here have traded at county-record prices.
Star Island was completed in 1922, dredged from the floor of Biscayne Bay by the Army Corps of Engineers during Carl Fisher's transformation of Miami Beach. It was conceived around a yacht club and platted as a single clockwise loop — Star Island Drive — with every estate lot fronting the water. That plat is the island's entire product: what was drawn in 1922 is, structurally, what trades today.
No mainland street can reproduce it: one gate, thirty-four lots, all of them on the water, ten minutes from South Beach and Downtown alike.
Ownership here has carried marquee names from music, sports and finance for decades, which does two things to the market: it keeps demand global, and it keeps most transactions quiet. Star Island trades are as likely to close privately as they are to appear on the MLS — which is why the record book, not the listing feed, is the honest measure of this market.
Verified against public records and press · Live lot-level data activates with our MLS feed
Star Island sits in Biscayne Bay just off the MacArthur Causeway — the nearest of the causeway islands to South Beach, with Palm and Hibiscus Islands immediately west and the Port of Miami's main channel, Government Cut, to the south.
The geography does the work: a single bridge controls entry, the loop road means no through traffic, the perimeter plat puts every lot on protected water, and the open Atlantic is minutes away by boat. South Beach and Downtown Miami are each roughly ten minutes by car.
Each sale is stored with property, date and source trail · Full MLS sales history activates with our live feed · Current homes for sale will publish here when live inventory is connected
Buyers who want the single most liquid trophy address in South Florida — maximum security, maximum recognition, every lot on the water, and a resale market that reaches every global buyer pool.
One-gate security with city proximity; a uniform waterfront plat with no lesser interior tier to drag comparables; deep-water dockage minutes from the ocean; the strongest record-sale history in Miami-Dade.
Fame cuts both ways — the island draws tour boats on the bay, and attention with them. With only 34 lots, inventory can sit at zero for long stretches, and entry often requires an off-market approach.
Palm Island for the same 1922 island program with a broader price ladder; Gables Estates for gated waterfront acreage with club-approval privacy; Indian Creek for the only address with comparable security cachet.
The 82-acre neighbor — waterfront estates plus interior lots, a broader price ladder behind the same style of guarded bridge.
Explore →Hibiscus IslandThe quieter twin between Palm and Star — same 1922 program, lower profile, strong rebuild activity.
Explore →North Bay RoadMiami Beach's mainland-side estate corridor — gated properties and wide bay views without an island gate.
Explore →Sunset IslandsFour guard-gated islands off Sunset Harbour — estate scale with a walkable neighborhood at the bridge.
Explore →Gables EstatesGated waterfront acreage in Coral Gables — a different expression of privacy, land value and boating access.
Explore →Indian CreekThe 41-home private village with its own police force — Star Island's only rival for security cachet.
Explore →There is one entrance — a single bridge from the MacArthur Causeway — and a staffed guard gate screens visitors around the clock. Access is effectively limited to residents and their guests.
Yes. The island was platted as a single loop with 34 estate lots, every one fronting Biscayne Bay. There are no interior lots and no condominiums.
26 Star Island Drive sold for $120 million in March 2025, reported as the Miami-Dade County residential record at closing. 8 Star Island Drive closed for $75 million in December 2021, reported as the county record at that time.
Yes — lots carry private docks with protected deep-water frontage on Biscayne Bay, minutes by boat from Government Cut and the open Atlantic.
Much of the island's activity is private. HL Real Estate Group tracks current and off-market availability across all 34 estates — request a consultation and we will map the real picture for you.
Speak with an HL Real Estate Group advisor. We'll compare the island against your full shortlist — waterfront, dockage, privacy, land value and provenance — and tell you honestly where we'd buy.
HL Real Estate Group · Advisory Team